I found out the other day that Louis Leterrier, better known as the director of the Transporter movies and the most recent Incredible Hulk cinematographic catastrophe, will be helming a remake of the fantasy classic Clash of the Titans.
For those of you not old enough or geeky enough to know about this film, it was released in 1981 and directed by Desmond Davis, better known for… pretty much nothing else, except a long list of TV productions.
The original Clash of the Titans is considered by many prominent experts in the field, including myself of course, to be one of the finest Greek Mythology films ever made, even if the title is misleading (there are no Titans in the film, only Gods) and Medusa’s blood looks suspiciously like spaghetti sauce. Also, if we’re going to be anal about it, the Kraken, which Perseus kills at the end of the film to rescue the gorgeous Andromeda, is actually a sea monster from Norwegian Mythology and is never mentioned in the Perseus/Andromeda myth, but that’s also a minor issue. As is the weird mechanical owl Hephaestus builds for Perseus.
The point is, overall the film sticks pretty closely to the myth and features special effects that were cutting edge at the time.
Press forward to 2010. Some director whose better achievements include fast cars, slow plots and a green radioactive monster no one seems to care about, decides to do a remake. He keeps the name, still doesn’t put any actual Titans in the Clash of the Titans, but this time sends Perseus to the underworld…
This is the Yahoo Synopsis and I am really hoping they got it wrong.
Ok… Perseus was NEVER in the Underworld, his family was NOT killed by Hades and he certainly did not fight Hades to keep him from taking over Olympus because Hades never tried to take over Olympus. Sadly, this is the second time I see Hades portrayed as a villain and this director seems to have pulled his plot straight from Walt Disney’s Hercules, one of the most inaccurate Greek Mythology-based films ever made, even if it was wildly entertaining (James Woods as Hades is still one of my favorite villains).
I was willing to forgive the Disney version mainly because it is, after all, a cartoon. I could write an entire week of blogs on how many things are wrong with that film, but I’ve watched it dozens of times and I love it anyway. My issue with this remake, is the same issue most people have with remakes of some of the best classics: it is unnecessary. Much like the remakes of Planet of the Apes and The Day the Earth Stood Still were unnecessary. In fact I think most movies with Keannu Reeves are unnecessary.
My even bigger issue with this particular remake is that, if Yahoo’s synopsis is right, it is blatantly ignoring the source material. Mainly, by bringing together two story lines from Greek Mythology that never crossed paths, and by portraying Hades as a villain.
Hades, the God of the Underworld, is never represented in Greek Mythology as an evil God. If anything, he was a moody and depressed God. Call him the original emo. Unlike his two brothers Zeus and Poseidon, he didn’t get to pick his job; he got what was left.
This is what happened. (If you already know the story or are just not interested in a free lesson in Mythology, you can stop reading now)
The Olympians had just won the war against the Titans, having kicked their titanic asses all the way back to the center of the Earth, and were celebrating by drinking lots of Ambrosia, which is the Olympian version of a Margarita, and dividing the world among themselves. The three main brothers were Zeus, Poseidon and Hades. They also had three sisters, Hera, Demeter and Hestia (yes, Zeus married his sister, get over it, this was Olympus, Alabama) but they didn’t get to participate cause Zeus was a chauvinistic jackass and had all three of them in the kitchen preparing the Margaritas.
So the three top dogs sit around and play a game of Poker… or something to that effect, to figure out who gets to pick their cubicle first. Zeus, who is always pushing everyone around because he thinks he’s got the biggest… uh… thunderbolt, wins and gets to pick first. Naturally, he claims the skies as his own, proclaims himself king of the Gods and proceeds to have sex with every female within sight, human or divine. Any time he shows up after this in a myth, he is either trying to get into someone’s pants or doing his best to keep his wife/sister from killing whoever owns the pants he just got into.
Moving on.
Poseidon wins second pick and he’s cool with not getting the sky cause he doesn’t like it all that much. He’s a seafood lover and enjoys long walks by the beach. He promptly claims domain over the entire ocean, which gives him plenty of real estate and a whole lot of lobster and cute mermaids. Poseidon is just about as promiscuous as Zeus but gets to do it less often mainly because all that sea water tends to cram his style and shrink his… possibilities. He takes a dive into his realm after this and only emerges every now and then to chase down some human girl or ruin Odysseus’ adventures.
Hades apparently was not too keen on the rules of Poker and never realized his two brothers were just bluffing so, naturally, he lost. He got stuck with the only thing that was left, the Underworld, which was not only dark, gloomy and a little moldy but also full of dead people. Regardless, he takes his new gig, sets up shop in Tartarus and hires three old hags called the Fates to handle his appointments. His most prominent break from this job happens when he decides that if he’s going to play undertaker to the whole damn planet, he wants to at least get laid regularly like his brothers.
After trying several dating services and coming to the conclusion that “Hey baby, wanna come live in my underground kingdom of darkness with a bunch of dead people?” was not as effective a pickup line as he had expected, he loses patience and decides to just kidnap a girl. This is the one and only time Hades plays the villain in a myth and in the end he doesn’t even get to keep his girl full time. The reason for this, is that unfortunately the girl he kidnaps is Persephone, daughter of Demeter (and yes, his niece, which is not as bad as Zeus marrying his sister… ok, maybe it is). Demeter is not longer preparing Margaritas. Instead she is running the entire natural world including the weather and is not known for her patience.
Well, naturally, mommy is not happy with his baby girl’s forceful relocation so she promptly brings about a planet-wide ice age. This concerns Zeus tremendously because in the frozen wasteland the world has become, humans are dropping dead like flies and if all the human girls die, he might be forced to have sex with his wife.
So Zeus, who incidentally is also Persephone’s daddy (this is one disfunctional family, I know) gets Hades on the phone and lets him know he’s got to return the girl or else he will send the D.E.P. after him. Hades whines and groans but finally says, “Fine, I’ll go get her.” Ten minutes later he gets back on the phone and lets Zeus know Persephone ran across the Underworld’s country buffet and because of some ancient rule… or maybe a rule Hades made up on the spot, she has to stay in the Underworld until her check clears through… or for all eternity, whichever comes first.
Well after many treaties and negotiations and lawyer fees, Persephone is allowed to return home to her mother, but she only gets to stay for six months and then she spends the other six months back in the Underworld. Demeter is not happy with this arrangement but Zeus is still in charge and he tells her it’s a done deal. In retaliation Demeter creates Wisconsin… no, wait… the seasons. Basically the half of the year that Persephone spends in the underworld everyone in the surface gets to wear coats, shovel snow and go skiing in Aspen… or freeze to death instead, whatever.The rest of the year, Persephone comes home to mommy and that’s what we call Spring and Summer.
So next time you look outside and the flowers are blooming and the sun is shinning and the birds are singing just remember, down in the Underworld, Hades isn’t getting any.
Originally Published 08/27/2009